In an unusual move aimed at addressing shoplifting in Michigan, Judge Jeffrey Clothier has proposed a distinctive penalty for perpetrators: free car washes. Situated in the 67th District Court in Genesee County, Judge Clothier suggested that individuals caught shoplifting from Walmart should perform this service as a way to compensate the community and deter future offenses. However, his initiative has faced a major setback after being overruled by the Chief Judge.
Chief Judge William Crawford II nullified the proposal, stressing that Judge Clothier should have sought approval from him and other court officials before opting for such a unique form of punishment. Judge Crawford emphasized that any alternative sentencing that deviates significantly from traditional methods requires prior consent. “Walmart Washes” will consequently not occur as initially planned, he announced in a recent statement.
Judge Clothier first brought his inventive idea to light in February, noting that he intended for up to 100 petty thieves to return to Grand Blanc Township, near Flint, to wash cars for free when the spring weather was more accommodating. He believed the plan had the support of local Walmart managers. However, when the corporate headquarters in Arkansas were made aware of the scheme, they declined to allow the car washes on their store premises. Despite this setback, Clothier was optimistic about relocating the event elsewhere.
This optimism was curtailed with Crawford’s disapproval. “I’m frustrated,” Judge Clothier admitted, adding that he is determined to find innovative ways to solve the ongoing issue of retail theft. Citing an uptick in these offenses, he noted, “I had 37 new Walmart theft offenses two days ago. In the last month, it’s been well over 100.” His efforts have garnered support, with about 20 to 30 judges from across Michigan expressing willingness to participate in the initiative. Although the plan has been halted, Clothier remains committed to exploring more creative solutions.
