ABC News’ parent company, Disney, quickly settled Donald Trump’s defamation lawsuit for $15 million last week, citing concerns over damaging press protections and avoiding a potential Supreme Court challenge to landmark First Amendment rulings.
Judge’s ruling prompted Disney’s action
A July ruling by Judge Cecilia Altonaga rejecting Disney’s motion to dismiss Trump’s lawsuit raised concerns about the network’s ability to win the case. The judge noted that a reasonable jury could find anchor George Stephanopoulos’ repeated claim that Trump was found liable for rape defamatory.
Decision influenced by potential jury bias
Disney executives feared a Florida jury might favor Trump, given the trial’s location and Trump’s political influence, leading to higher damages.
Settlement terms
Disney agreed to pay $15 million, cover Trump’s legal fees, and issue a statement expressing regret over the error.
Concerns over First Amendment protections
Legal experts and media pundits warn the settlement could embolden public figures to target press freedoms, with fears that future cases might challenge New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, a critical First Amendment precedent.
Backlash from media and legal observers
Critics, including media and Democratic lawyers, called Disney’s decision a capitulation, raising concerns about the precedent it sets for journalistic independence and legal protections for the press.
Trump’s next target: The Des Moines Register
Following his legal victory, Trump has sued The Des Moines Register over an inaccurate pre-election poll, further stoking concerns about the chilling effect on media organizations.
