Fred Costello has become a legendary figure in the world of baseball, but not as the player he originally dreamed of becoming. Born in Syracuse, New York, Costello grew up with ambitions of being the next Mickey Mantle, but his baseball journey ended after a stint in semi-pro leagues. Yet, his passion for baseball found another pathway as he carved out a career as one of the longest-serving sports organists, entertaining fans with his music for the Rochester Red Wings since 1977.
Celebrating his 89th birthday recently, Costello prepared for his 48th season behind the keyboard before the team’s home opener. Throughout his nearly five-decade career, he has missed only three games and has kept track of all the tunes he’s performed—from Frank Sinatra to Taylor Swift. As he reached his 3,458th game with the Red Wings, Costello reveled in surpassing Mantle’s number of appearances, joking about how athletes like Mantle might have benefitted from modern musical hype like walk-up songs.
Although Costello performs the traditional “Take Me Out to the Ball Game,” he continually updates his repertoire with contemporary hits, keeping both young fans and himself invigorated. He speaks with admiration for the latest music trends, mentioning a fondness for Shaboozy’s “Bar Song.” His commitment to music and baseball fuels his intention to keep playing into his 90s, delighting in each opportunity to craft a memorable atmosphere for fans and players.
The ballpark is a family affair for Costello, whose wife, Cathie, works in the Red Wings’ administration and whose children grew up contributing to the baseball scene. This year, the couple anticipates celebrating their 60th wedding anniversary, all the while cherishing their deep-rooted connection to Rochester and its baseball community.
Before settling in Rochester, Costello enjoyed a career as a touring musician, performing with greats like Bobby Darin and Doc Severinsen. His jazz roots run deep, having hosted a jazz show on local radio and performing in festivals with his band. These musical ties influence his ballpark performances, where he blends jazz, blues, classic rock, and Latin tunes to stand apart from his peers.
Costello’s move to Rochester came about somewhat serendipitously. Seeking stability with a growing family, he took on a new role as an organist for the Red Wings through a connection with then-general manager Don Labbruzzo. He signed a one-year contract back in 1977 and, much to his delight, never left.
While Costello flirted with opportunities in major leagues, including offers from the Yankees and Mets, he chose to remain faithful to Rochester, a place that had become his second home. The support from the Red Wings and the chance to bring joy through music have solidified his place in the community.
In an era when digital tunes often overshadow live music at ballparks, his proud tradition of real organ music endures. His dedication to the craft has been recognized with numerous honors, including Hall of Fame inductions and a Fred Costello Day in Rochester. Costello’s enduring love for music and baseball ensures that his melodies will continue to resonate with ballpark visitors for years to come.
In reflection, Costello sees no reason to halt his joyful ride with music. He passionately says that he’ll keep sharing his melodies with others “until I get it right,” a declaration of both artistry and enduring spirit.