The Los Angeles County District Attorney has publicly declared opposition to the resentencing of Lyle and Erik Menendez, arguing that the brothers have consistently fabricated their reasons for killing their parents in 1989. The DA stressed the lack of “insight and complete responsibility” shown by the brothers, particularly concerning false claims from their trial where they initially denied the killings.
The brothers’ ongoing defense that they acted in self-defense contradicts evidence demonstrating premeditated actions designed to stage the murders as a gang-related hit.
“The Menendez brothers have been deceitful for three decades,” he remarked. Drawing parallels to the Sirhan Sirhan case, the DA noted similarities in public support and low-risk inmate evaluations. However, Sirhan’s parole was denied by Governor Gavin Newsom in 2022, highlighting lingering concerns about public safety threats. He deemed the Sirhan case illustrative, as the lack of full accountability parallels the Menendez brothers’ situation.
The DA conveyed potential support for resentencing if the brothers ultimately admit to their past dishonesty before the court, the public, the DA’s office, and their family. Despite the DA acknowledging the brothers’ notable rehabilitation, such as earning degrees and maintaining low risk levels, his stance remains unchanged absent a full, truthful acknowledgment of their actions.
A resentencing hearing is scheduled for later in March.
New developments, including evidence of sexual abuse by their father, have bolstered the brothers’ appeal for freedom, gaining backing from many extended family members.
The Justice for Erik and Lyle Coalition reacted to the DA’s assertions, insisting that the brothers have evolved and atoned significantly over the past three decades. They claimed the brothers have expressed sincere remorse both publicly and personally, yet condemned the DA’s insistence on a specific, public apology for past actions made under duress.
After assuming office in December, the DA opposed a new trial for the siblings, now in their 50s, who are serving life sentences after their 1996 conviction for their parents’ murders.
His opposition contrasts with previous recommendations from former District Attorney George Gascón, who advocated for potential parole eligibility via resentencing.
Additionally, the brothers have sought clemency from Governor Newsom, who held off pending the DA’s review. The governor has since instructed the state parole board to evaluate the potential risks associated with the brothers’ possible release.
While Governor Newsom has yet to comment on the DA’s recent news conference, he did propose on Monday a new parole board process, similar to the current review of the Menendez brothers, that could lead to the reduction of more prison sentences.
Tamara Goodall, a cousin of the brothers, previously called for the DA’s removal due to perceived bias, a request the DA has declined while committing to abide by the law and evidence.
