An investigation has been initiated into the coaching staff at Bay FC, following alarming findings of a “toxic” work environment published in a recent report. This action was confirmed by National Women’s Soccer League Commissioner. The San Francisco Chronicle brought to light at least two formal complaints regarding the management of the team led by Coach Albertin Montoya.
In this report, two former unidentified players and employees labeled the team’s environment as unhealthy. One complaint from the team was investigated internally without finding any wrongdoing, while the specifics surrounding the second complaint remain unclear. Bay FC responded, stating that an independent third-party investigation had cleared them of any misconduct. The league has likewise launched an external independent review to shed more light on the matter.
During a conference call preceding the NWSL Challenge Cup match between Orlando Pride and Washington Spirit, Berman tackled the issues raised in the report. She emphasized the league’s commitment to a safe and healthy work environment and reaffirmed confidence in the process to bring issues to the fore to create optimal working conditions across all clubs.
As of now, no specific timeline has been set for the completion of the league’s investigation. This marks the second instance this year Bay FC has faced scrutiny, following the resignation of Graeme Abel, the head of domestic scouting, due to allegations of verbal misconduct in February.
The NWSL encountered a severe abuse and misconduct scandal back in 2021, leading to the dismissal or resignation of five coaches and subsequent investigations by both U.S. Soccer and the league with the players’ union. As a comprehensive response, the league introduced measures like enhanced vetting processes for employees and an anonymous reporting system for players.
A $5 million fund was recently set up as part of a settlement to support abuse victims, complementing the existing safeguards. This settlement involved the attorneys general from Washington D.C., Illinois, and New York.
According to the Chronicle, some former players and employees left the San Jose team following the last season, citing Montoya’s conduct, including claims about targeting players and bullying those who opposed him. The investigation drew from testimonies of numerous past and present players, as well as officials and league sources.
Bay FC stated that they have been addressing “communication challenges” identified from a player survey during the midseason of the previous year, and reported improvements were noted in subsequent surveys. Moving forward, the club is committed to continuing improvements through executive coaching and clear cultural framework development to ensure a supportive environment for players.
The team is actively addressing the feedback received from the league about communication issues, underlining the importance of creating a player-centric atmosphere for all club members and taking necessary actions as determined by the ongoing review.
