INDIANAPOLIS — The vacant trophy case visible to the Penn State players during their meetings is emblematic of both the team’s journey and the leadership of their coach, James Franklin. This decision to display the empty case was intentional, serving as a reminder of the goals yet to be accomplished since Franklin took over the program a decade ago, with the exception of one trophy from 2016.
With the upcoming Big Ten title game against the undefeated Oregon team, the Nittany Lions and their coach have a chance to fill that void. They also have potential access to the College Football Playoff, which is likely to include No. 3 Penn State regardless of the outcome against the Ducks. “We’ve aimed to fill up one of our empty cases, and that’s the next goal,” sophomore linebacker Tony Rojas stated. “The quest for the Big Ten championship starts with Coach Franklin and us.”
Over his 11 seasons, Franklin has established an impressive track record. His 99-40 record, five appearances in the AP Top 15, and regular invitations to celebrated bowl games like the Rose, Cotton, and Fiesta bowls place him among the most respected coaches in college football. Known for treating players like family and emphasizing accountability, Franklin embodies values that resonate deeply at Penn State, especially following the legacy of the school’s long-term former coach, Joe Paterno.
Arriving from Vanderbilt, where he revitalized a struggling SEC program, Franklin took on a challenging task shortly after the damaging fallout from the Sandusky scandal, which had severely affected Penn State’s reputation. Understanding the need for a delicate approach, he blended respect for Paterno’s history with a modern vision for the team. “We’ll do everything we can to bring this community back together,” Franklin expressed when he became head coach in 2014, emphasizing pride in the program.
However, expectations at Penn State extend far beyond mediocrity. The program has a rich history, boasting two national championships and multiple perfect seasons. As a result, many fans scrutinize Franklin’s record, noting his struggles against top-tier opponents, including a 1-10 record against Ohio State and a 3-18 mark against teams ranked in the top 10. Some fans express frustration, believing although Franklin secures numerous victories, he fails in crucial matchups.
“I definitely understand the frustration,” remarked Steelers’ tight end Pat Freiermuth, who played for Franklin from 2018 to 2020. Conversely, supporters appreciate the depth of the challenge Franklin confronted in 2014, as he inherited a team reeling from sanctions and scholarship reductions brought about by the scandal’s aftermath.
This season marks a significant achievement, as it is the first time since the early 1980s that Penn State has the potential to achieve three consecutive seasons with double-digit victories. “He takes over a team with empty cupboards,” commented Penn State legend LaVar Arrington earlier this year. “For him to rebuild Penn State into a program of respectability was a monumental task.”
The expanded College Football Playoff format might also be a positive development for Franklin and the Nittany Lions. Despite their recent loss to Ohio State, which featured missed scoring opportunities, Franklin emphasized the positive perspective on their accomplishments. “Nobody is scrutinizing our efforts more than I am,” he said. “Many programs would envy the success we’ve achieved here.”
The new playoff system could serve as an opportunity for Penn State to seek further success. Even if they hadn’t qualified for this year’s Big Ten title game, they are likely contenders for the playoff, having been frequently listed among the top 12 by the committee. “Regardless of how this game against Oregon plays out, making a deep run in the playoffs could mitigate some of the scrutiny faced by Coach Franklin,” said Freiermuth.
For now, however, Franklin remains focused solely on Oregon, recognizing the challenge ahead while putting thoughts of the empty trophy case aside. “I appreciate the inquiry, but our complete focus is on defeating the top-ranked team in the nation,” Franklin concluded, emphasizing the importance of the upcoming game.