INDIANAPOLIS — The start of the season was challenging for the Indianapolis Colts defense, as it struggled tremendously. The unit had difficulties stopping the run, preventing touchdowns, and getting off the field. However, things have changed remarkably.
Under the guidance of defensive coordinator Gus Bradley, the Colts’ defense has tightened up considerably. They have been able to hold opponents, including the high-powered Detroit Lions, to manageable scores, giving the Colts a fighting chance in games, despite their offensive struggles. “They are playing their tails off,” running back Jonathan Taylor expressed following the Colts’ 24-6 defeat on Sunday. “It sucks when you can’t help your defense out when they are fighting their tails off all game.”
In the recent matchup against the Lions, the Colts defense performed efficiently, restricting Detroit to only 14 points in the first half, ultimately limiting them to their lowest scoring output (24 points) since Week 3. However, the setback still looms for the Colts (5-7) since despite creating opportunities, their offense failed to sustain drives or capitalize on scoring chances.
Quarterback Anthony Richardson led the rushing attack with 61 yards on 10 attempts, primarily in the early stages of the game, while Taylor managed only 35 yards on 11 carries. Their efforts were hindered by a staggering 10 penalties that continuously set the Colts back. Lions coach Dan Campbell noted, “We knew Jonathan Taylor was going to be the guy we needed to shut down. We did that,” indicating that the defensive strategy worked effectively to negate the Colts’ run game.
Indy’s offensive line is also grappling with injuries, having seen three rookies start in the last two games. With so many factors at play, it’s clear that the Colts need to find solutions fast. There is glimmer of hope on Indianapolis’ horizon: their schedule is set to get easier. After enduring four losses in five games against teams in playoff contention, only one of their remaining five opponents has a winning record. Their last game against a team with a losing record saw Richardson lead them to a thrilling 28-27 victory over the New York Jets.
However, Colts coach Shane Steichen understands that relying solely on easier opponents won’t solve their issues. He emphasized the pressing need for the team to rejuvenate their offense. “We’ve got to get that figured out. We’ve got to get him going on the ground,” he stated regarding Taylor’s performance, noting that Taylor has accumulated just 92 yards in his last 35 carries.
On a positive note, the Colts’ pass rush has been productive, largely due to Pro Bowl defensive tackle DeForest Buckner’s return from a sprained ankle. Since his comeback five games ago, the defense has accumulated 14 sacks, including three against Jared Goff in their latest encounter.
However, one area that requires immediate attention is penalty issues. Up until Sunday, the Colts had a reputation for maintaining cleaner operations compared to other teams. The lapses in discipline during their last game need addressing to ensure they don’t derail future efforts.
In individual performances, wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. has been a bright spot. Despite dealing with a back injury that affected his output, Pittman shined with 11 receptions for 142 yards since missing Week 10, including a notable game with six catches for 96 yards, his second-highest total of the season. Conversely, the tight ends remain a disappointment. Drew Ogletree’s missed touchdown opportunity was particularly painful, as it would have shifted the momentum in favor of the Colts. To date, the tight ends have produced meager stats with just 26 catches for 299 yards and two touchdowns this season—falling short in an era where productive tight ends are becoming crucial.
On the injury front, both Pittman and WR Josh Downs returned to action after briefly leaving with shoulder injuries, while WR Ashton Dulin did not return due to a foot injury. The offensive line’s health remains a significant concern as left tackle Bernhard Raimann was inactive, and rookie center Tanor Bortolini has entered concussion protocol, adding to the challenges since Pro Bowler Ryan Kelly is on injured reserve.
Looking at the key metrics, the Colts have managed to score touchdowns on 55.88% of their red zone trips this season, placing them squarely in the middle of the NFL rankings—something that has led to missed opportunities and close defeats.
Next steps for the Colts include a crucial rebound for Richardson, who needs to elevate his game following an unremarkable 11 of 28 passing performance. The Colts will look to capitalize on their remaining matchups, starting with an upcoming game against the New England Patriots as the final month of the season approaches.