From an early age, it was clear that Garr was destined for a career in the arts. She was born to Eddie Garr, a prominent vaudeville comedian, and Phyllis Lind, one of the original Rockettes at New York’s Radio City Music Hall. Garr’s journey in dance began at the tender age of six, and by fourteen, she was performing with ballet companies in San Francisco and Los Angeles.
When she was sixteen, Garr joined the traveling company of “West Side Story” in Los Angeles, marking a pivotal moment in her career. She recounted during a 1988 interview how persistence led her to secure a role in this iconic production. After an initial setback in her auditions, she returned the following day, presenting herself in a new outfit, which ultimately won her a spot.
Following her success in “West Side Story,” the tall and striking Garr maintained a steady flow of work in the film industry, particularly as a dancer. She showcased her talents in the chorus for nine films starring Elvis Presley, including notable titles such as “Viva Las Vegas,” “Roustabout,” and “Clambake.” Through her versatile skills, Garr carved out a special place for herself in the entertainment industry and left an enduring legacy.