In a shocking twist, former college soccer star Matthew Hertgen has been arrested for the brutal murder of his younger brother Joseph and his cat in a luxury New Jersey apartment. The crime has left both the local community and those who knew the Hertgen family in disbelief. Matthew, 31, faces severe charges, including first-degree murder, animal cruelty, and multiple weapons offenses. The tragic event took place in the upscale Michelle Mews Apartments in Princeton.
Tragic discovery in Princeton
Princeton Police responded to a terrifying 911 call reporting a fire and a dead body inside the Michelle Mews Apartments. Officers quickly arrived at the scene. They found Matthew at the residence. He was identified as the caller. Inside, they discovered his brother’s lifeless body. The cat was also found dead. The crime scene was both shocking and disturbing. Authorities believe Matthew brutally attacked his brother using a knife and a golf club. The injuries Joseph suffered were severe. Prosecutors revealed blunt force trauma and deep lacerations on his body. The exact cause of death is pending the results of an autopsy.
A violent attack
The brutal nature of the crime has shocked many. Matthew is suspected of intentionally killing his younger brother. Authorities also believe he caused the death of the family cat. The attack appeared to be both deliberate and violent. The injuries Joseph sustained were not accidental. He was found with severe trauma that led to his death. Matthew’s actions have left investigators searching for a clear motive. Right now, the exact reason for the attack remains unknown.
A life of privilege
The Hertgen brothers grew up in a life of wealth and privilege. Their father, David Hertgen, is a successful tech mogul. He is the president of WiLine Networks, a company that generates millions in revenue. The family lived in a lavish four-bedroom mansion in Toms River, New Jersey. The home was valued at $1.2 million. It featured a swimming pool and plenty of space for a comfortable lifestyle. David and his wife Debra raised their children in an affluent environment. The brothers had access to top-tier education and opportunities.
The brothers’ soccer careers
Both Matthew and Joseph were standout soccer players. Matthew played at Wesleyan University from 2011 to 2014. Joseph also excelled in soccer, playing at the University of Michigan from 2016 to 2019. Before attending college, both brothers were stars at Toms River North High School. Their athleticism and success on the field were well-known. Soccer was a major part of their lives, and they were admired by many. Joseph graduated in 2020 with a degree in Business Administration, Accounting, and Finance. He later worked as an analyst at Locust Point Capital, where he was building a promising career.
The high-end apartment complex
The Michelle Mews Apartments, where the crime occurred, are located in the upscale Palmer Square Residences in downtown Princeton. The apartments are known for their luxurious features. Renting for between $6,275 and $6,300 a month, these properties attract high-profile tenants. Their close proximity to Princeton University makes them even more desirable. The complex is a symbol of wealth and exclusivity. Residents of Michelle Mews are accustomed to a high standard of living, making this tragedy even more jarring.
A shocking crime with no clear motive
At this time, the motive behind the crime remains unclear. Investigators are still trying to piece together the events that led to Joseph’s death. What could have driven Matthew, a successful athlete, to murder his own brother? The Hertgen family had everything—wealth, success, and status. They seemed to live a perfect life. But this brutal crime has shattered that image. The motive for the attack is something authorities are working hard to uncover.
Tributes and shocked friends
The news of Joseph’s tragic death has shocked friends and family. Many have taken to social media to share memories of the young man. Tributes have poured in, remembering Joseph as a kind, talented, and loving individual. Friends described him as “the best of the best.” One friend posted, “My heart is broken for your family and friends who became family. Fly high Hertgen.” Another wrote, “Absolutely insane. Rip to a great soccer player and person.” The outpouring of support is a testament to the love and respect Joseph earned throughout his life.
