Just a couple of years ago, anti-abortion activists rejoiced as the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the Roe v. Wade decision, potentially ending abortion rights nationwide. However, as the presidential election draws near, the movement is facing division and concern. There is internal discord, second-guessing, and apprehension that Election Day could reveal the lack of broad support for their cause.
Michael New, a pro-life advocate at The Catholic University of America, reflected on the movement’s progress since the Roe ruling in June 2022. He acknowledged that things have not unfolded as hoped, with pro-life leaders feeling the need for a stronger post-Roe strategy.
Anti-abortion activists have faced setbacks with recent defeats on abortion-related ballot measures in conservative states like Kansas and Kentucky. As nine more states prepare to consider amendments protecting abortion rights in the upcoming election, the movement anticipates challenges in blocking these measures due to significant funding support from pro-abortion groups and the Democratic Party.
Despite the obstacles, Carol Tobias, president of National Right to Life, remains resolute in educating people about the perceived consequences of passing these measures. She highlights the uphill battle due to financial backing from opponents and emphasizes the unwavering determination within the pro-life community.
While some states have implemented near-total abortion bans, nationally, the anti-abortion movement finds itself at a critical juncture. There is a realization that despite legal successes, public opinion has not shifted entirely in their favor.
Notably, Troy Newman of Operation Rescue criticized the movement for what he sees as failures over the past decades. He emphasized the importance of focusing on protecting babies and blamed internal leadership for certain shortcomings.
Kristan Hawkins of Students for Life of America acknowledges the challenges ahead, particularly in the face of late-term abortion referendums. She emphasizes the need for a strategic and well-funded state-wide approach to counter pro-abortion efforts effectively.
Former President Donald Trump’s stance on abortion and his endorsement of a state-by-state approach have also caused rifts within the anti-abortion movement. Some activists feel that Trump’s strategy diverges from their goals, prompting soul-searching within the movement.
The conflicting views on Trump and his abortion stance have led to divisions among anti-abortion leaders, with some expressing disappointment and urging voters to withhold support, while others believe Trump offers better prospects for advancing pro-life causes at the federal level. The movement is navigating these political challenges while striving to unify and mobilize against perceived threats to the pro-life agenda.
