Eagles’ Sirianni defends use of ‘tush push’ tactic

In Indianapolis, the Philadelphia Eagles’ head coach, Nick Sirianni, firmly defended the use of the “tush push” play amidst discussions sparked by a proposal from the Green Bay Packers to ban it. At the NFL’s scouting combine, Sirianni expressed his frustration with the proposal, emphasizing the significant effort and detailed preparation the team invests into perfecting the play. He noted, “I almost feel a little insulted because we work so hard at that play,” highlighting the practice, coaching, and talent that contribute to its success.

The “tush push” technique, effectively utilized by Philadelphia in short-yardage scenarios with quarterback Jalen Hurts, has become a distinctive part of their strategy. It involves teammates collaboratively pushing Hurts to secure the necessary yardage for first downs or touchdowns. The play has proven successful for the Eagles over the last three seasons, notably contributing to their 40-22 triumph over the Kansas City Chiefs in Super Bowl 59.

Green Bay Packers’ general manager, Brian Gutekunst, acknowledged the team’s proposal aimed at banning the play, classifying it as a modified quarterback sneak that many teams have struggled with. While discussions on the proposal are still forthcoming, he noted, “We really haven’t had very many discussions about it. I’m sure we will over the next few weeks.” The fate of this proposal will be in the hands of the NFL Competition Committee and team owners, who are set to deliberate and possibly vote on the issue during their upcoming meeting in Florida.

The Eagles’ innovative approach has inspired several teams to adopt similar strategies, including the Buffalo Bills. Despite experiencing mixed success, with a notable failure in a critical playoff game against Kansas City, the approach remains a point of contention. In defense of the play’s continued use, Sirianni remarked on the unique skill set his team possesses to execute it and dismissed the notion of its automatic success as unfair.

Challenges faced during the use of the “tush push” were exemplified during Philadelphia’s NFC championship game against the Washington Commanders. The play’s impact on defenses was evident as the Commanders repeatedly jumped offside in attempting to counter the strategy. Conversely, the Packers have historically struggled both to execute and defend against the play, prompting further examination.

Mark Murphy, Packers’ president and CEO, criticized the play as “bad for the game,” suggesting it lacks skill and unfairly guarantees a first down in short-yard situations. Nonetheless, opinions within the NFL are divided. Atlanta Falcons coach Raheem Morris is among those supporting the ban, while others, like Tampa Bay Buccaneers coach Todd Bowles, argue that teams should adapt defensively rather than eliminating the play.

Debate within the league extends to player safety concerns, with Bills coach Sean McDermott highlighting potential risks. Conversely, Sirianni refuted injury claims, asserting, “I think that’s a little made up,” citing the absence of injury incidents tied to the play during its extensive use by the Eagles.

Opinions vary, with Ravens coach John Harbaugh offering a holistic perspective. He argued for consistency in rule enforcement, stating, “You can’t take one out and not the other,” referencing similar plays involving offensive pushes. The debate over the “tush push” will likely remain a heated topic as the NFL evaluates its rules and regulations.