Reality Star List of Hookups Explodes in latest Memoir

July 22, 5:33 PDT

Keypoints Summary:

Scheana Shay drops bombshells in new memoir My Good Side
Reality star opens up about celebrity flings and hookups
Confirms Jesse Metcalfe, Shemar Moore, Eddie Cibrian
Reveals connections to John Mayer, Jesse McCartney, JC Chasez
Two unnamed stars from The Notebook included
Adds encounters with NFL, NBA, and MLB athletes
Book teases more names with subtle hints and juicy clues
Fans shocked by how open and unapologetic she is

Okay, let’s be real. I cracked open Scheana Shay’s memoir expecting a few spicy stories and maybe a Vanderpump Rules drama flashback or two. What I got? A full-blown celebrity hookup saga with enough famous names to make your head spin. This isn’t just tea—it’s a full boiling kettle. From musicians to athletes to actors we all crushed on in the 2000s, the Reality Star List of Hookups just got a massive new chapter.

Scheana Shay Blows the Lid Off Her Hollywood Past

In My Good Side, Scheana doesn’t hold back. She owns her past, her hookups, and her headline-worthy nights out like a pro. This isn’t a sanitized version of stardom. It’s raw. It’s real. And it’s dripping in name drops.

Let’s start with the boldest reveals. She confirms past hookups with Jesse Metcalfe, Eddie Cibrian, and Shemar Moore. That’s Desperate Housewives, Young & the Restless, and Criminal Minds all in one page.

But the surprises don’t stop there. Scheana also name-checks John Mayer, Josh Hopkins, Shane West, Jesse McCartney, JC Chasez, Adrian Grenier, and Ricardo Chavira. Did we just time-travel to TRL in 2006? Because that lineup screams teen heartthrob overload.

And if that wasn’t enough—she casually drops that she connected with two actors from The Notebook. She doesn’t name names, but we all have guesses. Gosling? Marsden? Cassavetes? The mystery alone has fans on fire.

The Reality Star List of Hookups Hits the Sports World Too

Scheana doesn’t limit her love life to red carpet regulars. She also reveals intimate moments with professional athletes, including players from the NFL, NBA, and MLB.

She keeps the names private—maybe to avoid jersey burnings—but hints that some were household names. According to the book, one MLB star flew her out for a weekend getaway. An NBA player slid into her DMs with poetry. And an NFL player once showed up at SUR just to get her number.

This section of the memoir isn’t just juicy—it’s a peek into how celebrity dating culture works behind the scenes. No dating apps. Just parties, DMs, and very strategic VIP invites.

Scheana’s stories blur the line between fame and flirtation. And it shows just how connected the reality TV world really is to the biggest stages in sports and music.

Scheana Shay Owns Her Story and Shuts Down the Shame

What makes this memoir pop isn’t just the names—it’s the attitude. Scheana tells it all with zero shame and zero apology. She owns her sexuality, her dating history, and her desire to have fun. She doesn’t portray herself as a victim. She’s not chasing validation. She’s telling her truth.

At one point in the book, she writes: “I wasn’t looking for forever. I was looking for fun, connection, and experience. And I got that, in ways I never expected.”

That honesty is refreshing in a world where stars either hide their past or try to rewrite it. Scheana flips the script. She turns her hookup history into empowerment.

And fans are eating it up.

Fans React to the Bombshells With Shock and Applause

The internet is doing what it does best—losing its mind. Scheana’s memoir went from just another reality star tell-all to a trending topic. TikTok is full of reaction videos. BookTok is dissecting every chapter. And fans are placing bets on who those mystery Notebook actors might be.

Some fans are in shock: “I thought Jesse McCartney was with Katie Cassidy back then—this is WILD.”

Others are proud: “Honestly? Get it girl. That’s an A-list lineup and I respect it.”

And then there are the conspiracy theorists, trying to decode every hint Scheana drops about the anonymous athletes and actors.

It’s giving chaos. It’s giving icon behavior.

Could This Book Change Her Public Image?

For years, Scheana Shay has been portrayed as the boy-crazy SURver, always looking for love and never quite getting it right. But this book? It changes that narrative. It shows a woman who’s lived, learned, and laughed—often at herself.

She’s not ashamed of her history. She embraces it. She even pokes fun at it. And that confidence might just be what finally flips the public’s perception of her.

From side character to main event, Scheana just leveled up.